Pavlov: Does That Name Make You Drool? A Guide to Respondent Conditioning

Say the name “Pavlov” in a room full of behavior analysts and someone will joke about drooling. The joke works because Ivan Pavlov’s dogs are one of the most famous examples in all of psychology. But Pavlov’s work is more than trivia. It is the foundation of respondent (classical) conditioning, a concept you need for the BCBA exam and for understanding fears, emotional reactions, and many everyday behaviors. This guide explains who Pavlov was, what he discovered, and how it shows up in ABA.

Key takeaways

  • Pavlov was a Russian physiologist who discovered respondent (classical) conditioning while studying digestion in dogs.
  • Respondent conditioning pairs a neutral stimulus with an unconditioned stimulus until the neutral stimulus alone elicits a response.
  • Five key terms: unconditioned stimulus (US), unconditioned response (UR), neutral stimulus (NS), conditioned stimulus (CS), and conditioned response (CR).
  • Respondent behavior is elicited by stimuli that come before it; operant behavior is controlled by its consequences.
  • It matters in ABA for understanding fears, emotional responses, and why some stimuli acquire reinforcing or aversive functions.

Who was Ivan Pavlov?

Ivan Petrovich Pavlov (1849–1936) was a Russian physiologist. Ironically, he was not trying to study learning at all. His research focused on digestion, and in 1904 he received the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine for that work.

While measuring how much dogs salivated when food was placed in their mouths, Pavlov and his colleagues noticed something odd: the dogs began salivating before the food arrived, at the sight of the lab assistant or the sound of footsteps. Pavlov realized that the dogs had learned to associate these stimuli with food. He spent the rest of his career studying this “psychic secretion,” which we now call respondent or classical conditioning.

The famous experiment

Pavlov’s procedure, in simplified form, went like this:

PhaseWhat happenedWhat it shows
Before conditioningFood in the mouth produced salivation. A sound (such as a metronome or buzzer) produced no salivation.Food is an unconditioned stimulus; the sound is a neutral stimulus.
During conditioningThe sound was presented just before the food, many times.The neutral stimulus is paired with the unconditioned stimulus.
After conditioningThe sound alone produced salivation.The sound has become a conditioned stimulus that elicits a conditioned response.

Popular retellings usually say Pavlov used a bell. He and his colleagues actually used a variety of stimuli, including metronomes, buzzers, and lights. The bell has simply become the most memorable version of the story.

The five key terms

These five terms appear constantly on the BCBA exam. See the glossary for respondent conditioning for a quick definition.

TermDefinitionIn Pavlov’s experiment
Unconditioned stimulus (US)A stimulus that elicits a response without any prior learningFood
Unconditioned response (UR)The unlearned response elicited by the USSalivation to food
Neutral stimulus (NS)A stimulus that does not elicit the response before conditioningThe sound, before pairing
Conditioned stimulus (CS)A formerly neutral stimulus that elicits a response after being paired with a USThe sound, after pairing
Conditioned response (CR)The learned response elicited by the CSSalivation to the sound

Exam tip: salivation is both the UR and the CR. What changes is the stimulus that elicits it. Ask yourself, “Did this response need to be learned in the presence of this stimulus?” If not, it is unconditioned.

Beyond the basics: extinction, recovery, and more

  • Respondent extinction: if the CS is presented repeatedly without the US, the CR weakens and eventually stops. The sound alone, over and over, with no food, stops producing salivation.
  • Spontaneous recovery: after extinction and a period of rest, the CR may briefly reappear when the CS is presented again.
  • Higher-order conditioning: a CS can be paired with a new neutral stimulus until the new stimulus also elicits the CR. For example, a light paired with the sound (which already elicits salivation) can come to elicit salivation too, without food ever being paired with the light.
  • Stimulus generalization and discrimination: stimuli similar to the CS may elicit the CR (generalization). With training, the CR can be limited to the original CS (discrimination).
  • Habituation: a separate, unlearned process in which repeated presentation of a US produces a weaker UR. It is not the same as respondent extinction, which involves a learned CS.

Respondent conditioning in everyday life

  • Your phone’s notification sound makes your heart rate jump after it has been paired many times with stressful messages.
  • The smell of a hospital produces anxiety after past painful procedures there.
  • A song brings on a rush of emotion because it was playing during a meaningful event.
  • A child begins crying at the sight of the doctor’s white coat after shots were paired with it.
  • Your dog drools at the sound of the can opener, because that sound has been paired with food many times. Pavlov would be proud.

Pavlov vs. Skinner: respondent vs. operant conditioning

Respondent (Pavlov)Operant (Skinner)
What controls the behaviorStimuli that come before the responseConsequences that come after the response
How behavior occursElicited (reflexive)Emitted (voluntary)
Key procedureStimulus–stimulus pairingReinforcement and punishment
Typical responsesSalivation, heart rate, fear, startleTalking, writing, requesting, completing tasks
ExampleA dog salivates at a sound paired with foodA dog sits because sitting has produced treats

For a deeper comparison, read Understanding Respondent and Operant Conditioning.

Why Pavlov matters in ABA

  • Fears and phobias. Many fears develop through respondent conditioning, and treatments such as systematic desensitization and exposure rely on respondent extinction and counterconditioning.
  • Pairing to build rapport. When therapists pair themselves and the teaching area with preferred items and activities, they help neutral stimuli become conditioned reinforcers. This is a stimulus–stimulus pairing process with roots in Pavlov’s work.
  • Emotional responses during treatment. Respondent behavior, like crying or a racing heart, often occurs alongside operant behavior. Understanding both helps BCBAs design kinder, more effective interventions.
  • Exam content. Respondent conditioning is part of the Concepts and Principles domain of the BCBA Test Content Outline.

Test yourself

Practice question 1

A child was stung by a bee while playing near a buzzing beehive. Now the child cries and freezes whenever she hears buzzing. In this example, the buzzing sound is the:

  • A. Unconditioned stimulus
  • B. Conditioned stimulus
  • C. Unconditioned response
  • D. Conditioned response
Show the answer

B. Conditioned stimulus. The buzzing was neutral before it was paired with the painful sting (the US). Now the buzzing alone elicits fear, so it is a conditioned stimulus, and the crying and freezing to the buzzing are the conditioned response.

Practice question 2

After conditioning, a researcher presents the tone many times without food, and the dog stops salivating to the tone. The next day, the tone produces a small amount of salivation again. This is called:

  • A. Habituation
  • B. Higher-order conditioning
  • C. Spontaneous recovery
  • D. Stimulus generalization
Show the answer

C. Spontaneous recovery. The conditioned response reappeared after a rest period following respondent extinction.

Master concepts and principles, one task at a time

The free BCBA Study Checklist covers every 6th edition task, including respondent and operant conditioning, so you can track exactly what you have mastered.

Pavlov FAQ

What did Pavlov discover?

Pavlov discovered respondent (classical) conditioning: when a neutral stimulus is repeatedly paired with a stimulus that naturally elicits a response, the neutral stimulus alone comes to elicit a similar response.

Did Pavlov really use a bell?

Pavlov and his colleagues used several types of stimuli, including metronomes, buzzers, and lights. The bell is the most popular version of the story, but it is a simplification.

What is the difference between a US and a CS?

An unconditioned stimulus (US) elicits a response without learning, such as food producing salivation. A conditioned stimulus (CS) elicits a response only after it has been paired with a US.

Is respondent conditioning the same as classical conditioning?

Yes. Behavior analysts usually use the term respondent conditioning; classical conditioning and Pavlovian conditioning refer to the same process.

How is Pavlov different from Skinner?

Pavlov studied respondent behavior, which is elicited by stimuli that come before it. Skinner studied operant behavior, which is controlled by the consequences that follow it.

About the author

Dr. Jaime Flowers, Ph.D., BCBA, is a Board Certified Behavior Analyst and the creator of ABA Study Guide, which helps BCBA candidates study one checklist item at a time. Read more about Jaime.

Last reviewed: November 20, 2026.

References

  • Cooper, J. O., Heron, T. E., & Heward, W. L. (2020). Applied behavior analysis (3rd ed.). Pearson.
  • Pavlov, I. P. (1927). Conditioned reflexes: An investigation of the physiological activity of the cerebral cortex (G. V. Anrep, Trans.). Oxford University Press.
  • Behavior Analyst Certification Board. (2022). BCBA test content outline (6th ed.).

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top