A child hears “ball” and says “ball.” A student copies the word CAT from the board. A learner sees the sign for “more” and makes the same sign. These look like three different skills, but in verbal behavior they belong to one category: the duplic. This guide explains what a duplic is, its three types, how it differs from a codic, where it fits among the verbal operants, and why the echoic is so important in early language teaching.
Key takeaways
- A duplic is a verbal operant controlled by a verbal stimulus, where the response has both point-to-point correspondence and formal similarity with that stimulus.
- There are three types: the echoic (vocal to vocal), copying a text (written to written) and imitation of signs (sign to sign).
- A codic also has point-to-point correspondence, but no formal similarity: textual behavior (reading) and transcription (writing from dictation).
- Like other verbal operants controlled by a verbal stimulus, duplics are typically maintained by generalized conditioned reinforcement.
- Echoics are a foundation skill: they are the basis for echoic prompts used to teach mands, tacts and intraverbals.
In this guide
What is a duplic?
Skinner (1957) described the echoic, textual and other “elementary verbal operants.” Jack Michael (1982) later grouped them by two features of the relation between the verbal stimulus and the response:
- Point-to-point correspondence: each part of the stimulus controls a matching part of the response. The beginning of the stimulus controls the beginning of the response, the middle controls the middle, and so on.
- Formal similarity: the stimulus and response are in the same sense mode and look or sound alike. Hearing a word and saying it are both auditory; seeing a written word and writing it are both visual.
A duplic is a verbal operant that has both. The response is, in effect, a copy of the verbal stimulus that evoked it.
The three types of duplics
| Type | Verbal stimulus | Response | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| Echoic | Spoken (heard) | Spoken | A teacher says “cookie,” and the child says “cookie.” |
| Copying a text | Written (seen) | Written | A student sees “dog” on the board and writes “dog.” |
| Imitation of signs (sometimes called mimetic) | Sign (seen) | Sign | A therapist signs MORE, and the learner signs MORE. |
Duplic vs. codic
The easiest way to remember duplics is to compare them with codics. Both have point-to-point correspondence, but a codic changes sense modes, so there is no formal similarity.
| Duplic | Codic | |
|---|---|---|
| Point-to-point correspondence | Yes | Yes |
| Formal similarity | Yes (same sense mode) | No (different sense modes) |
| Types | Echoic, copying a text, imitation of signs | Textual behavior (reading aloud), transcription (writing what you hear, or taking dictation) |
| Example | Hearing “apple” and saying “apple” | Seeing “apple” and saying “apple” (textual) |
A quick test: if the response would look or sound like the stimulus if you put them side by side, it is a duplic. If the response is the same word in a different form, such as speech from print or print from speech, it is a codic.
Duplics among the verbal operants
| Verbal operant | Controlled by | Correspondence with stimulus | Typical reinforcement |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mand | Motivating operation | No verbal stimulus | Specific reinforcement (what was asked for) |
| Tact | Nonverbal stimulus (something seen, heard, felt) | No verbal stimulus | Generalized conditioned reinforcement |
| Intraverbal | Verbal stimulus | No point-to-point correspondence | Generalized conditioned reinforcement |
| Duplic (echoic, copying a text, imitation of signs) | Verbal stimulus | Point-to-point correspondence and formal similarity | Generalized conditioned reinforcement |
| Codic (textual, transcription) | Verbal stimulus | Point-to-point correspondence, no formal similarity | Generalized conditioned reinforcement |
Is all imitation verbal behavior?
No. Imitating a clap, a wave or a block design is motor imitation: the model is a nonverbal stimulus, so the behavior is not verbal. Imitation of signs counts as a duplic because the model is a sign, a verbal stimulus in a sign-language repertoire, and the response is part of that same verbal repertoire.
Motor imitation is still an important skill. Many early learners are taught generalized motor imitation first, which can make imitating signs and other new responses easier to teach.
Why echoics matter in early language teaching
- Echoic prompts. Once a learner can echo, the instructor can say a word as a prompt (“Say juice“) and then fade it, transferring control to a motivating operation (a mand) or an object (a tact).
- Shaping speech. Echoic training lets instructors shape clearer articulation by reinforcing closer and closer approximations to the model.
- Assessment. Language assessments such as the VB-MAPP include an echoic assessment (the Early Echoic Skills Assessment) to measure how well a learner repeats sounds, words and phrases.
- Not the end goal. An echoic repertoire alone is not functional communication. If a learner only repeats what others say, the next step is transferring those words to mands, tacts and intraverbals.
How this shows up on the BCBA exam
Verbal operants are tested in the Concepts and Principles domain of the BCBA Test Content Outline (6th ed.), and teaching them shows up in Behavior-Change Procedures. Expect questions that:
- Describe a response and ask you to name the verbal operant (echoic, textual, copying a text, transcription, tact, mand or intraverbal).
- Ask which features a duplic has (point-to-point correspondence and formal similarity) or how it differs from a codic.
- Ask whether a form of imitation is verbal behavior.
- Describe echoic prompts in mand or tact training.
Test yourself
Practice question 1
A teacher writes “SUN” on the whiteboard. A student looks at it and writes “SUN” in her notebook. Which verbal operant is this?
- Textual
- Transcription
- Copying a text
- Tact
Show the answer
3. Copying a text. The stimulus and response are both written and look alike (formal similarity), with point-to-point correspondence. That makes it a duplic. Reading the word aloud would be textual; writing it from dictation would be transcription.
Practice question 2
Which feature does a duplic have that a codic does not?
- Point-to-point correspondence
- Control by a verbal stimulus
- Formal similarity
- Generalized conditioned reinforcement
Show the answer
3. Formal similarity. Both duplics and codics have point-to-point correspondence and are controlled by verbal stimuli. Only duplics have formal similarity, meaning the stimulus and response are in the same sense mode.
Practice question 3
An instructor holds up a picture of a car and says, “Say car.” The child says “car.” The instructor then fades the vocal prompt until the child says “car” when shown the picture alone. What is happening?
- Transferring stimulus control from an echoic to a tact
- Teaching an intraverbal
- Transferring a mand to an echoic
- Teaching transcription
Show the answer
1. The child first responds to the spoken model (an echoic). Fading the prompt transfers control to the picture, a nonverbal stimulus, which makes the response a tact.
Related reading: Echoic (glossary) · Imitation (glossary) · Tact (glossary) · Intraverbal (glossary) · Behavior Cusps and Pivotal Behaviors
Duplic FAQ
What is a duplic in verbal behavior?
A duplic is a verbal operant in which the response has point-to-point correspondence and formal similarity with the verbal stimulus that evoked it. The three types are the echoic, copying a text and imitation of signs.
Is an echoic a duplic?
Yes. An echoic (hearing a spoken word and repeating it) is the most common type of duplic.
What is the difference between a duplic and a codic?
Both have point-to-point correspondence with a verbal stimulus. A duplic also has formal similarity (the same sense mode, such as speech to speech). A codic does not (such as print to speech in textual behavior, or speech to print in transcription).
Who came up with the term duplic?
Jack Michael introduced the terms duplic and codic in 1982 to group Skinner’s elementary verbal operants by their relation to the verbal stimulus.
References
- Cooper, J. O., Heron, T. E., & Heward, W. L. (2020). Applied behavior analysis (3rd ed.). Pearson.
- Michael, J. (1982). Skinner’s elementary verbal relations: Some new categories. The Analysis of Verbal Behavior, 1, 1–3.
- Skinner, B. F. (1957). Verbal behavior. Appleton-Century-Crofts.
- Sundberg, M. L. (2008). Verbal Behavior Milestones Assessment and Placement Program: The VB-MAPP. AVB Press.