All learned behavior comes down to two processes. Respondent conditioning explains how reflexes become linked to new stimuli, like a dog salivating at the sound of a bell. Operant conditioning explains how consequences shape what we do, like a child asking politely because it gets results. This guide explains both, the key terms you need to know, how their extinction processes differ, and how to tell them apart on the BCBA exam.
Key takeaways
- Respondent behavior is elicited by a stimulus that comes before it. It is reflexive.
- Operant behavior is emitted and controlled by the consequences that follow it.
- Respondent conditioning pairs a neutral stimulus with an unconditioned stimulus until the neutral stimulus elicits a response on its own.
- Operant conditioning uses reinforcement to increase behavior and punishment to decrease it.
- Extinction works differently: respondent extinction removes the pairing; operant extinction removes the reinforcement.
In this guide
Two kinds of behavior
Behavior analysts separate behavior into two broad types, and each is learned in a different way:
- Respondent behavior is reflexive. It is elicited: reliably produced by a stimulus that comes immediately before it. Examples include salivating when food is in your mouth, blinking when air hits your eye, or your heart racing at a loud noise.
- Operant behavior is emitted: it operates on the environment and is shaped by what happens after it. Examples include talking, reaching, writing, asking for help, or leaving a room.
On the BCBA exam, this falls under Domain B, Concepts and Principles (24 scored questions), especially task B.3 (respondent vs. operant conditioning) and task B.11 (operant vs. respondent extinction).
What is respondent conditioning?
Respondent conditioning (also called classical or Pavlovian conditioning) happens when a neutral stimulus is repeatedly paired with an unconditioned stimulus, until the neutral stimulus alone elicits a response. In Ivan Pavlov’s famous research, dogs naturally salivated to food. After a sound was repeatedly paired with food, the sound alone produced salivation.
| Term | Definition | Pavlov example |
|---|---|---|
| Unconditioned stimulus (US) | Elicits a response without any prior learning | Food |
| Unconditioned response (UR) | The unlearned response to a US | Salivating to food |
| Neutral stimulus (NS) | Does not elicit the response before conditioning | Bell, before pairing |
| Conditioned stimulus (CS) | A former NS that now elicits a response because of pairing | Bell, after pairing |
| Conditioned response (CR) | The learned response to a CS | Salivating to the bell |
Other respondent processes to know
- Respondent extinction: the CS is presented repeatedly without the US, so it gradually stops eliciting the CR.
- Spontaneous recovery: after extinction, the CR briefly reappears when the CS is presented again later.
- Respondent generalization: stimuli similar to the CS also elicit the CR (for example, other tones, not just the original bell).
- Respondent discrimination: the CR occurs to the CS but not to other, different stimuli.
- Higher-order conditioning: a CS is paired with a new neutral stimulus, which then becomes a CS too.
- Habituation: a decrease in an unconditioned response after repeated presentation of the same stimulus (for example, no longer startling at a ticking clock).
In practice, respondent procedures such as systematic desensitization and counterconditioning are used to reduce conditioned fear and anxiety, for example toward haircuts, dentists, or dogs.
What is operant conditioning?
Operant conditioning is learning that happens because of consequences. When a behavior is followed by a consequence that makes it more likely to happen again, that is reinforcement. When the consequence makes it less likely, that is punishment. B. F. Skinner’s research made operant conditioning the foundation of applied behavior analysis.
Operant behavior is described with the three-term contingency (antecedent, behavior, consequence) or the four-term contingency, which adds the motivating operation:
Reinforcement and punishment
| Stimulus added (positive) | Stimulus removed (negative) | |
|---|---|---|
| Behavior increases | Positive reinforcement A child cleans her room and gets praise; room cleaning increases | Negative reinforcement Taking aspirin removes a headache; taking aspirin increases |
| Behavior decreases | Positive punishment Touching a hot stove produces pain; touching the stove decreases | Negative punishment A teen breaks curfew and loses phone time; breaking curfew decreases |
Operant extinction
Operant extinction happens when a behavior that was previously reinforced no longer produces reinforcement, so it decreases over time. Watch for an extinction burst (a temporary increase in the behavior, or new behaviors, when reinforcement first stops) and spontaneous recovery (the behavior briefly returning after it had decreased).
Respondent vs. operant conditioning: side by side
| Respondent conditioning | Operant conditioning | |
|---|---|---|
| Type of behavior | Reflexive, elicited | Voluntary, emitted |
| Controlled by | Antecedent stimuli (what comes before) | Consequences (what comes after) |
| Key process | Stimulus–stimulus pairing (NS + US) | Response–consequence relation |
| Key terms | US, UR, NS, CS, CR | SD, MO, reinforcement, punishment |
| Classic researcher | Ivan Pavlov | B. F. Skinner |
| Example | Feeling anxious at the sound of a dentist’s drill | Raising your hand because the teacher calls on you |
Operant vs. respondent extinction
| Respondent extinction | Operant extinction | |
|---|---|---|
| What happens | The CS is presented without the US | The behavior no longer produces reinforcement |
| What decreases | The conditioned response | The operant behavior |
| Example | The bell rings repeatedly with no food; salivation to the bell fades | A child’s tantrums no longer get attention; tantrums decrease over time |
When both happen together
Real behavior often involves both processes at once. A child who is bitten by a dog may develop a conditioned fear response to dogs (respondent: the dog was paired with pain). The child may then learn to avoid dogs, because crossing the street reduces that fear (operant: negative reinforcement). Effective intervention may need to address both, for example combining gradual exposure with reinforcement for approaching calmly.
Test yourself
Practice question 1
Every time a toddler receives a vaccine, the nurse wears a blue uniform. After several visits, the toddler begins crying as soon as he sees anyone in a blue uniform. In this example, the blue uniform is a(n):
- Unconditioned stimulus
- Conditioned stimulus
- Unconditioned response
- Discriminative stimulus
Show the answer
B. Conditioned stimulus. The blue uniform was originally neutral. After being paired with the painful shot (the unconditioned stimulus), it now elicits crying on its own, so it is a conditioned stimulus, and crying to the uniform is a conditioned response. A discriminative stimulus signals that reinforcement is available for an operant response, which is not what is happening here.
Practice question 2
A therapist stops giving attention when a child whines for a snack, and over the next two weeks the child’s whining decreases. Which process explains the decrease?
- Respondent extinction
- Negative punishment
- Operant extinction
- Habituation
Show the answer
C. Operant extinction. Whining was an operant behavior previously reinforced by attention, and that reinforcement was withheld, so the behavior decreased. It is not respondent extinction, because no conditioned stimulus is being presented without an unconditioned stimulus. It is not negative punishment, because nothing the child already had is removed contingent on whining. Habituation is a decrease in an unconditioned reflex to a repeated stimulus.
Master Domain B, one task at a time
Concepts and Principles has 24 tasks, more than any other domain. The free BCBA Study Checklist lists all of them so you can track exactly what you have mastered.
Respondent and operant conditioning FAQ
What is the difference between respondent and operant conditioning?
Respondent conditioning involves reflexive behavior that is elicited by a stimulus that comes before it; a neutral stimulus gains the power to elicit a response after being paired with an unconditioned stimulus. Operant conditioning involves behavior that is emitted and controlled by its consequences; reinforcement makes behavior more likely and punishment makes it less likely.
Is respondent conditioning the same as classical conditioning?
Yes. Respondent conditioning is also called classical or Pavlovian conditioning, after Ivan Pavlov’s research with dogs.
What are the five terms in respondent conditioning?
Neutral stimulus (NS), unconditioned stimulus (US), unconditioned response (UR), conditioned stimulus (CS), and conditioned response (CR).
What is the difference between operant and respondent extinction?
Respondent extinction happens when a conditioned stimulus is repeatedly presented without the unconditioned stimulus, so it gradually stops eliciting the conditioned response. Operant extinction happens when a behavior that was previously reinforced no longer produces reinforcement, so it gradually decreases.
What is the four-term contingency?
The four-term contingency describes operant behavior: a motivating operation (MO), a discriminative stimulus (SD), a response (R), and a consequence (such as a reinforcer, SR). The three-term contingency (SD–R–SR, or antecedent–behavior–consequence) leaves out the MO.
Can respondent and operant conditioning happen at the same time?
Yes. Many real-life behaviors involve both. For example, a child bitten by a dog may develop a conditioned fear response to dogs (respondent) and then learn to avoid dogs because avoiding them reduces that fear (operant, negative reinforcement).
Related reading: Understanding Differential Reinforcement: DRL, DRH, and DRD · A Comprehensive Guide to Preference Assessments · 20 Free BCBA Practice Questions
References
- Behavior Analyst Certification Board. (2022). BCBA test content outline (6th ed.).
- Cooper, J. O., Heron, T. E., & Heward, W. L. (2020). Applied behavior analysis (3rd ed.), Chapter 2: Basic concepts and principles. Pearson.
- Pavlov, I. P. (1927). Conditioned reflexes: An investigation of the physiological activity of the cerebral cortex (G. V. Anrep, Trans.). Oxford University Press.
- Skinner, B. F. (1938). The behavior of organisms: An experimental analysis. Appleton-Century.
- Skinner, B. F. (1953). Science and human behavior. Macmillan.