A Comprehensive Guide to Preference Assessments in ABA

Every reinforcement-based program depends on one thing: finding reinforcers that actually work. A preference assessment is how behavior analysts identify what a learner prefers, so those items can be used to teach new skills and reduce problem behavior. This guide covers every major type of preference assessment, how to run and score each one, how to choose the right method for your learner, and what the BCBA exam expects you to know.

Key takeaways

  • Purpose: identify items and activities a learner prefers, so they can be used as potential reinforcers.
  • Indirect vs. direct: interviews are quick but often inaccurate on their own. Direct assessments observe what the learner actually chooses.
  • Main direct methods: single stimulus, paired stimulus, MSW, MSWO (and brief MSWO), and free operant.
  • Choose by learner and setting: skills, time available, and whether removing items triggers problem behavior.
  • Preference is not proof: confirm with a reinforcer assessment, and reassess often because preferences change.

What is a preference assessment?

A preference assessment is a systematic way to identify which items, activities, or social interactions a learner prefers. The results guide which potential reinforcers to use during teaching. Because reinforcers drive almost every ABA intervention, choosing them well can be the difference between fast progress and none at all.

Preference is relative and changes over time. A child may love a tablet in the morning but lose interest after an hour of use (satiation), or want food more right before lunch (a motivating operation). Good preference assessment is an ongoing process, not a one-time task.

On the BCBA exam, preference assessments fall under Domain F, Behavior Assessment (23 scored questions), task F.4.

The four approaches to identifying preferences

Indirect

Ask

  • Interviews and checklists with caregivers, teachers, or the learner
  • Fast, but often inaccurate on its own
  • Best for building the list of items to test

Direct, free operant

Watch

  • Free access to all items; record engagement
  • No items are taken away
  • Good when removing items triggers problem behavior

Direct, trial-based

Offer choices

  • Single stimulus, paired stimulus, MSW, MSWO
  • Produce a ranked preference hierarchy
  • The most common approach in practice

Confirm

Test as reinforcers

  • A reinforcer assessment checks that a preferred item increases behavior
  • Preference does not guarantee reinforcement
  • Use when progress stalls

Indirect preference assessments

Indirect assessments ask people who know the learner well, or the learner themselves, what they like. Common tools are structured interviews, rating scales, and checklists, such as the Reinforcer Assessment for Individuals with Severe Disabilities (RAISD).

Indirect methods are fast and useful for building the list of items to test, but caregiver reports often do not match what a learner actually chooses. Use them as a starting point, then follow up with a direct assessment.

Types of direct preference assessments

MethodHow it worksHierarchy?TimeBest for
Single stimulusPresent one item at a time; record approach or engagementLimitedModerateLearners who cannot yet choose between two or more items
Paired stimulusPresent two items at a time; every item is paired with every other itemYes, detailedLongestA thorough, reliable ranking
MSWPresent an array; the chosen item is returned to the arrayPartialShortQuickly finding the top item
MSWOPresent an array; the chosen item is not returnedYes, full rankingShortAn efficient full ranking
Brief MSWOAn MSWO run with three arrays instead of fiveYesVery shortRepeating before every session
Free operantFree access to all items; record time engaged with eachYes, by durationVery shortLearners whose problem behavior is triggered by items being removed
MSW = multiple stimulus with replacement. MSWO = multiple stimulus without replacement.

Single stimulus preference assessment

Present one item at a time and record whether the learner approaches, takes, or engages with it, often across several presentations. Calculate the percentage of presentations each item was approached.

Pros: simple, and works for learners who cannot yet scan or choose between items. Cons: the learner may approach almost everything, which makes it hard to tell which items are more preferred.

Paired stimulus (paired choice) preference assessment

Present two items at a time and let the learner choose one. Every item is paired with every other item at least once, and the left/right positions are counterbalanced. With n items, you need n × (n − 1) ÷ 2 pairs: 5 items need 10 trials, 8 items need 28.

Selection %(Times the item was chosen ÷ Times the item was presented) × 100

Pros: produces a detailed, reliable ranking that tends to predict reinforcer effectiveness well. Cons: time-consuming with many items, and repeatedly removing items can trigger problem behavior for some learners.

Multiple stimulus with replacement (MSW)

Present an array of several items (often 5 to 8). The learner chooses one, has brief access to it, and the item is returned to the array. Repeat for several trials.

Pros: quick, and clearly identifies the top item. Cons: because the favorite stays available, the learner may choose it every time, so you learn little about the rest of the items.

Multiple stimulus without replacement (MSWO)

Present an array of items. After the learner chooses one and has brief access, that item is not returned. The remaining items are rearranged and presented again, until all items have been chosen or the learner stops choosing. The order of selection gives a full ranking. The original procedure, by DeLeon and Iwata (1996), repeated this across five sessions.

Pros: produces a full hierarchy in much less time than a paired stimulus assessment. Cons: the learner must be able to scan and choose from a larger array.

Brief MSWO

Carr, Nicolson, and Higbee (2000) showed that an MSWO run with three arrays instead of five could still identify effective reinforcers. Because it takes only a few minutes, it is practical to run before each teaching session to catch day-to-day changes in preference.

Free operant preference assessment

Give the learner free access to all items at once for a short period (Roane and colleagues used 5 minutes) and record how long they engage with each. Nothing is presented or removed during the assessment.

Pros: very quick, and research has found fewer problem behaviors than in trial-based formats, because items are never taken away. Cons: a learner may stay with one item the whole time, which tells you little about the others.

Worked example: scoring a paired stimulus assessment

A therapist runs a paired stimulus assessment with 5 items, so there are 10 pairs and each item is presented 4 times. Here are the results:

ItemTimes presentedTimes chosenSelection %Rank
Bubbles44100%1
Tablet4375%2
Puzzle4250%3
Music4125%4
Blocks400%5
High-preference items (top of the hierarchy) are the strongest candidates to test as reinforcers.

Bubbles (100%) and the tablet (75%) are high-preference items, the puzzle (50%) is moderate, and music and blocks are low. The next step is to confirm that bubbles actually works as a reinforcer for a target behavior.

How to choose the right preference assessment

Work through these questions in order:

  1. Does removing items lead to problem behavior? Start with a free operant assessment.
  2. Can the learner choose between items? If not yet, use a single stimulus assessment.
  3. Can the learner scan and choose from an array of several items? If yes, use an MSWO, or a brief MSWO for frequent reassessment.
  4. Can the learner choose between two items, but not from a larger array? Use a paired stimulus assessment.
  5. Do you only need the single top item, quickly? An MSW can work.

Whatever you choose, build the item list with an indirect assessment first, and include different kinds of items (edibles, toys, activities, and social interactions). Edible items are often chosen over leisure items, so consider assessing them separately.

Preference assessment vs. reinforcer assessment

A preference assessment tells you what a learner chooses. A reinforcer assessment tells you whether that item actually increases behavior when it is delivered contingent on a response. They are not the same: a learner may choose an item but not work for it.

  • Single operant arrangement: compare a target behavior with and without the item delivered contingent on it.
  • Concurrent operants arrangement: give two response options, each producing a different item, and see which the learner allocates more responding to.
  • Progressive ratio schedule: increase the response requirement each time to see how much work the learner will do for an item.

Common mistakes to avoid

  • Relying on interviews alone. Caregiver reports are a starting point, not a final answer.
  • Assessing once and never again. Preferences shift. Reassess regularly, and whenever progress stalls.
  • Mixing edibles and leisure items without thinking. Edibles can displace other items in the ranking.
  • Skipping position counterbalancing. Learners may favor one side of the table rather than one item.
  • Using items the learner can access freely all day. Free access reduces their value during teaching.
  • Assuming preferred means reinforcing. Check with a reinforcer assessment or by tracking performance.

Practice question

A BCBA needs to identify potential reinforcers for a learner who engages in aggression when preferred items are taken away. The BCBA wants a quick assessment that will avoid triggering aggression. Which preference assessment is most appropriate?

  1. Paired stimulus preference assessment
  2. Multiple stimulus without replacement (MSWO)
  3. Free operant preference assessment
  4. Single stimulus preference assessment
Show the answer

C. Free operant preference assessment. In a free operant assessment, the learner has continuous access to all items and nothing is removed during the assessment, which reduces the chance of triggering aggression maintained by access to tangibles. Paired stimulus, MSWO, and single stimulus assessments all involve presenting and then removing items on each trial.

Master Domain F, one task at a time

Behavior Assessment gained 5 questions in the 6th edition. The free BCBA Study Checklist lists all 8 Domain F tasks so you can track exactly what you have mastered.

Preference assessment FAQ

What is a preference assessment in ABA?

A preference assessment is a structured way to identify which items or activities a learner prefers, so they can be tested and used as potential reinforcers. Methods range from interviews (indirect) to observing free play (free operant) to offering structured choices (trial-based assessments).

What are the main types of preference assessments?

Indirect assessments (interviews and checklists), free operant assessments, and trial-based assessments: single stimulus, paired stimulus (also called paired choice or forced choice), multiple stimulus with replacement (MSW), and multiple stimulus without replacement (MSWO), including the brief MSWO.

Which preference assessment is the quickest?

Brief MSWO and free operant assessments are among the quickest. A brief MSWO uses three arrays instead of five, and a free operant assessment can be run in a few minutes. Both are practical to repeat before teaching sessions.

What is the difference between MSW and MSWO?

In a multiple stimulus with replacement (MSW) assessment, the selected item is put back in the array for the next trial. In a multiple stimulus without replacement (MSWO) assessment, the selected item is not put back, so the learner must choose among the remaining items, which produces a full ranking.

Is a preferred item always a reinforcer?

No. A preference assessment identifies items that are likely to function as reinforcers. To confirm, run a reinforcer assessment and show that making the item contingent on a behavior actually increases that behavior.

How often should preference assessments be done?

Preferences change with motivating operations, satiation, and time. Many practitioners run a brief assessment, such as a brief MSWO or a quick free operant check, before teaching sessions, and a more thorough assessment periodically or whenever progress stalls.

Related reading: Understanding Differential Reinforcement: DRL, DRH, and DRD · Types of IOA in Various Data Collection Methods · BCBA 6th Edition Task List Explained

About the author

Dr. Jaime Flowers, Ph.D., BCBA, is a Board Certified Behavior Analyst and the creator of ABA Study Guide, which helps BCBA candidates study one checklist item at a time. Read more about Jaime.

Last reviewed: November 20, 2026.

References

  • Behavior Analyst Certification Board. (2022). BCBA test content outline (6th ed.).
  • Carr, J. E., Nicolson, A. C., & Higbee, T. S. (2000). Evaluation of a brief multiple-stimulus preference assessment in a naturalistic context. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 33(3), 353–357.
  • DeLeon, I. G., & Iwata, B. A. (1996). Evaluation of a multiple-stimulus presentation format for assessing reinforcer preferences. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 29(4), 519–533.
  • Fisher, W., Piazza, C. C., Bowman, L. G., Hagopian, L. P., Owens, J. C., & Slevin, I. (1992). A comparison of two approaches for identifying reinforcers for persons with severe and profound disabilities. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 25(2), 491–498.
  • Fisher, W. W., Piazza, C. C., Bowman, L. G., & Amari, A. (1996). Integrating caregiver report with a systematic choice assessment to enhance reinforcer identification. American Journal on Mental Retardation, 101(1), 15–25.
  • Pace, G. M., Ivancic, M. T., Edwards, G. L., Iwata, B. A., & Page, T. J. (1985). Assessment of stimulus preference and reinforcer value with profoundly retarded individuals. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 18(3), 249–255.
  • Roane, H. S., Vollmer, T. R., Ringdahl, J. E., & Marcus, B. A. (1998). Evaluation of a brief stimulus preference assessment. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 31(4), 605–620.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top