Much of what we teach in ABA comes down to responding to the right stimulus at the right time. Simple discrimination teaches a learner which stimulus signals reinforcement. Conditional discrimination teaches a learner that the right answer depends on context. And equivalence-based instruction uses those discriminations to produce new skills that were never directly taught. This guide explains all three, with diagrams, examples, and BCBA exam practice.
Key takeaways
- Simple discrimination: one stimulus (SD) is always correct, and others (SΔ) are not.
- Conditional discrimination: which stimulus is correct depends on another stimulus, the sample.
- Match-to-sample is the standard procedure for teaching and testing conditional discriminations.
- Stimulus equivalence is shown by reflexivity, symmetry, and transitivity.
- Equivalence-based instruction trains a few relations and tests for new ones that emerge without teaching.
In this guide
What is a discrimination?
A behavior is under stimulus control when it occurs more often in the presence of one stimulus than another. Discrimination is the result: a learner responds differently to different stimuli. It develops through differential reinforcement, in which a response is reinforced in the presence of one stimulus (the SD) and not reinforced in the presence of another (the SΔ, or S-delta).
On the BCBA exam, these topics fall under task G.6 (simple and conditional discriminations), task B.21 (emergent relations and generative performance), and task G.19 (procedures that promote emergent relations).
Simple vs. conditional discrimination
Simple discrimination
In a simple discrimination, the same stimulus is always correct. A response is reinforced in the presence of the SD and not in the presence of the SΔ. This is the three-term contingency: SD → response → reinforcement.
- A child says “hi” when a person is present, but not to an empty room.
- A dog sits when it hears “sit,” but not when it hears “down.”
- A learner presses the green button (which produces a video) and not the red one.
Conditional discrimination
In a conditional discrimination, which stimulus is correct depends on another stimulus, called the sample or conditional stimulus. The same stimulus can be correct on one trial and incorrect on the next.
- Receptive identification: when the instructor says “touch cat,” the cat picture is correct; when she says “touch dog,” the dog picture is correct.
- Matching: a learner matches a printed word to its picture; the correct picture depends on which word is shown.
- Reading: selecting the printed word that matches a spoken word.
| Simple discrimination | Conditional discrimination | |
|---|---|---|
| Is the same stimulus always correct? | Yes | No; it depends on the sample |
| Contingency | Three-term (SD – R – SR) | Four-term (sample – SD – R – SR) |
| Example | Always touching the red card | Touching red only when told “red” |
| Common procedure | Differential reinforcement with SD and SΔ | Match-to-sample (MTS) |
Match-to-sample: how conditional discriminations are taught
- Present the sample (for example, the spoken word “dog” or a picture of a dog).
- Require an observing response, such as touching or naming the sample, so you know the learner attended to it.
- Present the comparisons, usually two to four, one of which is correct.
- Reinforce selecting the correct comparison, and use error correction for incorrect choices.
- Rotate positions and samples across trials so the learner cannot succeed by picking the same spot or the same card.
- Identity matching: the correct comparison is identical to the sample (picture to the same picture).
- Arbitrary matching: the correct comparison is not physically similar (spoken word to picture, printed word to picture).
What is stimulus equivalence?
Stimulus equivalence is shown when stimuli become interchangeable after only some relations among them are trained. Murray Sidman’s research in the 1970s and 1980s showed that teaching a few conditional discriminations can lead to many new relations emerging on their own.
| Property | What it means | Example (after A→B and A→C are taught) |
|---|---|---|
| Reflexivity | A stimulus is matched to itself (A=A) | Picture of a dog matched to the same picture |
| Symmetry | A trained relation works in reverse | Shown the picture (B), the learner selects the spoken word “dog” (A) |
| Transitivity / equivalence | Relations combine to form new ones | Shown the picture (B), the learner selects the printed word DOG (C), never trained directly |
Equivalence-based instruction (EBI)
Equivalence-based instruction is a teaching approach built on stimulus equivalence. Instead of teaching every relation directly, you teach a carefully chosen few, then test for the relations that emerge without teaching. In the example above, teaching two relations produced four more for free.
Why EBI matters
- Efficiency: fewer relations to teach directly, so more skills in less time.
- Generative performance: learners respond correctly to combinations they have never practiced.
- Wide range of uses: early reading, math facts, money, foreign-language vocabulary, and even college-level content such as statistics or neuroanatomy.
Steps in equivalence-based instruction
- Choose the stimulus classes you want to form (for example, spoken word, picture, and printed word for several animals).
- Pretest all relations to see what the learner already knows.
- Train a small set of baseline relations with match-to-sample (for example, A→B and A→C).
- Test for emergent relations (symmetry and transitivity/equivalence) without reinforcement.
- Retrain or adjust if emergent relations do not appear.
Common errors: faulty stimulus control
- Position bias: always choosing the card on the left. Fix by rotating positions.
- Attending to an irrelevant feature, such as a smudge on a card or the instructor’s glance. Fix by varying materials and avoiding inadvertent cues.
- Not attending to the sample: the learner picks a favorite comparison regardless of the sample. Fix by requiring an observing response.
- Prompt dependence: the learner waits for help. Fix by fading prompts systematically.
- Too few exemplars: the skill does not generalize. Fix by teaching with multiple examples from each stimulus class.
Test yourself
Practice question 1
A therapist places a cup, a ball, and a shoe on the table and says “touch ball.” The learner touches the ball. On the next trial, she says “touch cup.” Which type of discrimination is being taught?
- Simple discrimination
- Conditional discrimination
- Respondent discrimination
- Response generalization
Show the answer
B. Conditional discrimination. Which object is correct depends on the spoken instruction (the sample). The ball is correct on one trial and incorrect on the next, which defines a conditional discrimination. In a simple discrimination, the same stimulus would always be correct.
Practice question 2
A learner is taught to match the spoken word “seven” (A) to the numeral 7 (B), and the numeral 7 (B) to seven dots (C). Without further teaching, the learner matches seven dots (C) to the spoken word “seven” (A). This untrained relation is an example of:
- Reflexivity
- Symmetry only
- Combined transitivity and symmetry (equivalence)
- Stimulus generalization
Show the answer
C. Combined transitivity and symmetry (equivalence). The trained relations were A→B and B→C. Going from C back to A requires both combining relations (transitivity) and reversing them (symmetry), which is why this combined test is often called the equivalence test. Reflexivity is matching a stimulus to itself, and symmetry alone would be B→A or C→B.
Master stimulus control, one task at a time
The free BCBA Study Checklist covers every 6th edition task, including simple and conditional discriminations and emergent relations, so you can track exactly what you have mastered.
Discrimination and equivalence FAQ
What is the difference between simple and conditional discrimination?
In a simple discrimination, a response is reinforced in the presence of one stimulus (the SD) and not another (the S-delta), and the same stimulus is always correct. In a conditional discrimination, which stimulus is correct depends on another stimulus, called the sample or conditional stimulus.
Is receptive identification a conditional discrimination?
Yes. When a learner is asked to “touch cat” from an array of pictures, the correct picture depends on the spoken instruction. If the instruction changes to “touch dog,” a different picture becomes correct.
What is stimulus equivalence?
Stimulus equivalence is shown when stimuli become interchangeable after some relations among them are trained. It is demonstrated by tests of reflexivity, symmetry, and transitivity, and a combined test often called the equivalence test.
What are reflexivity, symmetry, and transitivity?
Reflexivity is matching a stimulus to itself (A=A). Symmetry is reversing a trained relation (if A→B is taught, B→A emerges). Transitivity is combining relations (if A→B and B→C are taught, A→C emerges). The combined test, such as C→A after A→B and B→C are taught, is often called the equivalence test.
What is equivalence-based instruction?
Equivalence-based instruction (EBI) is a teaching approach that directly trains a small number of conditional discriminations, then tests for relations that emerge without direct teaching. It can make teaching more efficient, because learners gain more relations than were taught.
What is match-to-sample?
Match-to-sample (MTS) is a procedure for teaching and testing conditional discriminations. A sample stimulus is presented, the learner makes an observing response, and then chooses from two or more comparison stimuli. In identity MTS the correct comparison is identical to the sample; in arbitrary MTS it is not physically similar.
Related reading: Understanding Stimuli and Stimulus Classes · Understanding Respondent and Operant Conditioning · BCBA 6th Edition Task List Explained
References
- Behavior Analyst Certification Board. (2022). BCBA test content outline (6th ed.).
- Cooper, J. O., Heron, T. E., & Heward, W. L. (2020). Applied behavior analysis (3rd ed.), Chapter 17: Stimulus control, and Chapter 19: Equivalence-based instruction. Pearson.
- Fienup, D. M., Covey, D. P., & Critchfield, T. S. (2010). Teaching brain–behavior relations economically with stimulus equivalence technology. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 43(1), 19–33.
- Sidman, M. (1971). Reading and auditory-visual equivalences. Journal of Speech and Hearing Research, 14(1), 5–13.
- Sidman, M., & Tailby, W. (1982). Conditional discrimination vs. matching to sample: An expansion of the testing paradigm. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 37(1), 5–22.